Let it snow! Mrs. Peabody’s 2019 Christmas crime fiction recommendations

Here are Mrs. Peabody’s 2019 Christmas crime fiction recommendations! Each is one of my top reads of the year, and will fit snugly into the Xmas stockings of all who’ve been good. Don’t forget to treat yourself, too!

Available from a wonderful local bookshop near you…

Jane Harper, The Lost Man, Abacus (Australia)

This novel was one of my most satisfying reads of the year. An in-depth character study of a family and their community, it’s also a page-turner that will keep you completely riveted for hours.

Cameron Bright is found dead in a remote part of his cattle station by the so-called ‘Stockman’s Grave’. The mystery of how and why he got there, and why his car is so far away become the subject of a police investigation. Cameron’s older brother Nathan, who owns the adjacent property, and his younger brother Bub both had complicated relationships with him, and further complexities and secrets soon start to be revealed. This is the third of Harper’s novels, and has a neat link back to her first, The Dry but no prior reading or knowledge is required. If you’re feeling generous, leave both for your lucky reader under the tree.

Seishi Yokomizo, The Honjin Murders, tr. Louise Heal Kawai, Pushkin Press 2019 (Japan)

I’ve just read The Honjin Murders, and immediately knew I had to add it to this list, because it’s the perfect gift for any fan of classic crime fiction or locked room mysteries. As an added bonus, it’s set in Japan! Plus: it’s the first in master crime writer Seishi Yokomizo’s acclaimed ‘Konsuke Kindaichi’ series, and the first to be translated (beautifully) into English.

It’s 1937, and the grand Ichiyanagi family is celebrating a family wedding. But that night, the family is woken by a terrible scream, followed by the sound of eerie music. Death has come to Okamura, leaving no trace but a bloody samurai sword, thrust into the pristine snow outside the house. It’s an impossible puzzle, but eccentric amateur detective Kosuke Kindaichi is determined to figure it out.

George Pelecanos, The Man Who Came Uptown, Orion (USA)

This quietly powerful crime novel interweaves the stories of three individuals. Anna Byrne is a prison librarian, who tries to better the lives of inmates through reading, and to broaden their horizons through regular book-group discussions. One of her readers is Michael Hudson, a bright young man who has gone off the rails, but is keen to go straight. When he’s suddenly released ahead of his trial, he’s relieved but can’t quite understand why. The answer lies with Phil Ornazian, a private investigator who regularly flirts with danger when making money illicitly on the side. Pelecanos was a scriptwriter for The Wire, and his characterisation of each of these figures is superb. The novel is also a wonderful homage to the life-changing power of reading.

Oyinkan Braithwaite, My Sister, the Serial Killer, Doubleday 2018 (Nigeria)

I gobbled up this wholly original Nigerian crime novel in one sitting. Korede is a plain, respectable nurse, who leads a neat and ordered life. Or rather, she would do if it weren’t for her volatile, beautiful younger sister, whose boyfriends seem to have a habit of winding up dead, and who expects big sis to sort everything out. I won’t give anything else away, but suffice to say that this is an arresting read, which deploys the darkest of humour to tell its story. The question at the heart of the novel is: how far would you go to protect a family member whose actions you know are criminal? It’s all very nicely done and a lot of fun.

John le Carré, Agent Running in the Field, Viking 2019 (UK)

It’s such a pleasure to step back into le Carré’s world and to meet a fresh cast of beautifully observed, but very human spies. Shown weaving their way through the complexities of modern politics as best they can, they soon learn that they need to keep a sharp eye on their own superiors as much as their adversaries elsewhere. Our guide to all this is Nat, an agent runner at the end of his career who’s asked to take over The Haven, a lowly substation of London General. He and a colleague begin to plan an operation targeting a Ukrainian oligarch, but then something strange happens… Light relief takes the form of regular badminton games with young Ed, an affable but somewhat mysterious figure who may be more than he seems. A completely convincing and gripping depiction of murky espionage shenanigans.

M.T. Edvardsson, A Nearly Normal Family, tr. Rachel Willson-Broyles, Macmillan 2019 (Sweden)

This accomplished novel tracks the fallout from a murder via the perspectives of three members of one family: a mother, a father, and a daughter who’s been accused of killing a well-connected, rich young man. An ostensibly ‘normal’ and respectable middle-class family – dad is a pastor, mum is a lawyer, and daughter Stella is unruly but bright – they are pushed to the limits by the stress of Stella’s arrest, detention and trial. The three points of view and family dynamics are beautifully handled, and there are plenty of surprises in store for the reader, even after the end of the trial. The novel is one of the submissions for the 2020 Petrona Award.

Rachel Kushner, The Mars Room, Vintage 2018 (USA)

This isn’t a conventional crime novel, but rather a novel about a crime and what comes next. Romy Hall is serving two consecutive life sentences at Stanville Women’s Correctional Facility after killing the man who was stalking her. Through her eyes, we’re shown the reality and bleakness of American prison life, and through her recollections, we trace her early years in San Francisco and the events leading up to the killing. At the centre of it all stands ‘The Mars Room’, the strip club where Romy worked to provide for her son Jackson. The novel explores the circumstances that shape Romy as an individual, the choices she makes, and how larger forces outside her control (such as the justice system) shape her destiny. Beautifully written – and shortlisted for the 2018 Booker Prize.

Jørn Lier Horst, The Katharina Code, tr. by Anne Bruce, Penguin 2018 (Norway)

The 2019 Petrona Award winner! The Katharina Code is one of my favourite things – a really gripping cold case. Every year, Chief Inspector William Wisting gets out his notes on the disappearance of Katharina Haugen, who vanished from her home twenty-four years earlier, leaving only a mysterious ‘code’ on the kitchen table, ‘a series of numbers arranged along three vertical lines’. This particular year, however, a development in another investigation finally moves the case on… An outstanding police procedural that takes established tropes – the cold case, the longstanding suspect, the dogged nature of police work – and combines them in ways that are innovative and fresh.

Jess Kidd, Himself, Canongate 2017 (Ireland)

Himself takes us back to the good old, bad old days. It’s Ireland in 1976, and Mahony, a young man brought up by nuns in a Dublin orphanage, returns to Mulderrig, a tiny rural village he recently found out was his birthplace. He is the son of Orla Sweeney, who scandalised the village with her wild behaviour as a young woman, and who disappeared in 1950. With the help of the eccentric Mrs. Cauley and a host of benign spirits who waft through walls, he starts uncovering the hypocrisies, secrets and malign power dynamics of the village. Utterly original, beautifully written and often wickedly funny, this is a crime novel to savour.

Happy reading, and wishing you all a wonderful and very merry Christmas!

26 thoughts on “Let it snow! Mrs. Peabody’s 2019 Christmas crime fiction recommendations

  1. Perfect timing, was just heading out to my local independent – thank-you Mrs P. “The man who came uptown” sounds perfect for my boss ( a Headteacher of a big secondary) who has recently introduced class reading every morning in school.

  2. What a great list! Thanks so much, there is still time for Santa to get me at least a few of these 🙂 Happy Christmas to you to, Mrs P!

  3. Thanks for adding to my wish list😂 I’ll request these from my library tomorrow and look forward to having a book binge ( and a gin or too) over the Christmas hols. Happy Christmas to you and your family, Karenx

    • You’re welcome, Karen! Because it’s not like we have enough books to read already, is it?! Happy reading and enjoy that gin… Wishing you and yours a wonderful Christmas too, and hope to see you in the New Year! xxx

  4. These are great suggestions, Mrs. P.! I keep meaning to read the Braithwaite and just…haven’t yet. I’m especially glad you recommended that one, as it reminded me it’s still on my wish list!

    • You’re very welcome, Jeremy. It’s always a pleasure to put the list together, and to have a think about which of my top reads would make good gifts. I thought The K Code was one of Lier Horst’s best ones yet – but the whole series is a delight. Lucky us!

  5. Thanks so much for introducing me to some very interesting books. The le Carre book and the one by Oyinkan Braithwaite were already on my radar, but I had not heard about the Pelecanos book, and there are several others in your list that I will follow up on. The Kushner book sounds like a very challenging read.

    • Hello Tracy – you’re very welcome. I really enjoyed the Pelecanos (I first came to his work many years ago when I read his novel The Big Blowdown on a long train trip – it was one of the most memorable reading experiences I’ve had). You’re right – the Kushner is a very challenging read, but there are also moments of lightness and even humour. It’s a book that will really stay with you, and is beautifully written.

  6. Morning Mrs P. A great selection there, especially The Lost Man which I anticipate getting to over Xmas sometime. Jane Harper made a very brief appearance in Neighbours last week with a box full of signed copies of The Lost Man for a charity auction. Yes I know, Neighbours a soap, but I have to have my full quota of Aussie soap therapy otherwise I mope, lol! The Le Carre and The Katharina Code appeal, as does Himself. Murder, mystery and humour. Right up my street.
    Wishing you and yours a very happy Xmas 🎄.

    • Hello Kathy! Can’t believe that Jane Harper was on Neighbours!!! Used to watch that every day in the 80s, but am probably a bit out of touch with developments now… Happy reading and have a wonderful Christmas x

  7. Nice to see an Australian entry on your list in the form of Jane Harper’s The Lone Man. A terrific read and better than The Dry IMHO. A stand out crime read for me this year was by The Godmother by Hannelore Cayre, translated from the French. It’s a diamond: hard, coming from a dark place, and absolutely sparkling.

    Happy reading into the new decade.

    • Hi Angela. I agree with you – I think The Lost Man just edged The Dry, though I also liked the way the two books were linked (very subtly) so that you could see each as an extension of the another, especially thematically.

      Thanks for that recommendation, which I’ve scribbled down. Sounds great.

      Happy reading, and wishing you and yours a happy festive season x

  8. Thanks for the recommendations. I agree on The Lost Man and My Sister, the Serial Killer. Several here look good, including The Katharina Code. It’s essential to have interesting books to read during the holidays.

    • I second that, Kathy D. Where would we be without interesting reads during the holiday season? Wishing you very happy reading and a restful, restorative few days x

  9. And here I am, with an article deadline over my head, sneaking back to The Katharina Code. So undisciplined here.
    This book is the definition of “a police procedural,” yet it is riveting I like that Wisting’s daughter is involved. Thankfully,
    not another lonely, alcoholic, depressed detective. A detective with a family down the road who has a healthy outlook.
    Unfortunately, it’s riveting.

  10. Pingback: Crime Fiction: Respite Reading for the Pandemic | Mrs. Peabody Investigates

Leave a Reply to Sue Gewanter Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.